|
Science 6 October 2006: |
A critical concern in the transmission of prion diseases, including chronic wasting disease (CWD) of cervids, is the potential presence of prions in body fluids. To address this issue directly, we exposed cohorts of CWD-naļve deer to saliva, blood, or urine and feces from CWD-positive deer. We found infectious prions capable of transmitting CWD in saliva (by the oral route) and in blood (by transfusion). The results help to explain the facile transmission of CWD among cervids and prompt caution concerning contact with body fluids in prion infections.
1 Department of
Microbiology, Immunology, and Pathology, College of Veterinary
Medicine and Biological Sciences (CVMBS), Colorado State University
(CSU), Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA.
2 Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory, College of Veterinary
Medicine and Biological Sciences (CVMBS), Colorado State University
(CSU), Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA.
3 Biological Resource Management Division, National Park
Service, Fort Collins, CO 80525, USA.
4 Wildlife Artist Supply Company (WASCO) Inc., Monroe, GA
30655, USA.
5 Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources,
University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30609, USA.
6 Wildlife Research Center, Colorado Division of
Wildlife, Fort Collins, CO 80526, USA.
7 Department of Microbiology, Immunology and Molecular
Genetics, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 40536, USA.
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: edward.hoover@colostate.edu
Excerpt:
Deer
cohorts 1 (blood), 2 (saliva), and 3 (urine and feces) were electively
euthanized at 18 months pi to permit whole-body examination
for PrPCWD. The greatest scrutiny was directed toward those tissues
previously established to have highest frequency of PrPCWD deposition in
infected deer and generally regarded as the most sensitive indicators of
infection—medulla oblongata and other brainstem regions, tonsil, and
retropharyngeal lymph node. We found unequivocal evidence of PrPCWD in brain
and lymphoid tissue of all six tonsil biopsy–positive deer in cohorts 1
(blood) and 2 (saliva), whereas all deer in cohorts 3 and 5 were negative
for PrPCWD in all tissues (Table 2 and Figs. 1 and 2). The
transmission of CWD by a single blood transfusion from two symptomatic and
one asymptomatic CWDž donor is important in at least three contexts: (i) It
reinforces that no tissue from CWD-infected cervids can be considered free
of prion infectivity; (ii) it poses the possibility of hematogenous spread
of CWD, such as through insects; and (iii) it provides a basis for seeking
in vitro assays sufficiently sensitive to demonstrate PrPCWD or alternate
prion protein conformers in blood—one of the grails of prion biology and
epidemiology. The identification of blood-borne prion transmission has
been sought before with mixed results (9–11). Bovine spongiform
encephalopathy and scrapie have been transmitted to naBve sheep through the
transfer of 500 ml of blood or buffy coat white blood cells from infected
sheep (12, 13). In addition, limited but compelling evidence argues for the
transmission of variant
Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD) through blood from asymptomatic donors
(14–16). Even in sporadic CJD, PrPres has been found in peripheral organs of
some patients (17). The present work helps establish that prion diseases can
be transmitted through blood. The presence of infectious CWD prions in
saliva may explain the facile transmission of CWD. Cervid-to-cervid
interactions (SOM text),
especially in high density and captive situations, would be expected to
facilitate salivary crosscontact (11, 18, 19). Salivary dissemination of
prions may not be limited to CWD. Proteaseresistant prion protein has been
demonstrated in the oral mucosa, taste buds, lingual epithelium, vomeronasal
organ, and olfactory mucosa of hamsters infected with transmissible mink
encephalopathy (19) and ferrets infected with CWD (20). Although no instance
of CWD transmission to humans has been detected, the present results
emphasize the prudence of using impervious gloves during contact with saliva
or blood of cervids that may be CWD-infected. Environmental contamination by
excreta from infected cervids has traditionally seemed the most plausible
explanation for the dissemination of CWD (21). However, we could not detect
PrPCWD in cohort 3 deer inoculated repeatedly with urine and feces from CWDž
deer and examined up to 18 months pi (Table 2). There are several reasons to
view this negative finding cautiously, including small sample size, elective
preclinical termination, and potential variation in individual
susceptibility that may be associated with the 96 G/S polymorphism in the
PRNP gene (7, 22). Although no genotype of white-tailed deer is resistant to
CWD infection, PRNP genotypes S/S or G/S at codon 96
appear to have reduced susceptibility manifest by longer survival (7). Both
deer in cohort 3 (urine and feces) were subsequently shown to
be of the PRNP 96 G/S genotype. Thus, it is possible, although we think
unlikely, that these deer had a prolonged incubation period (918
months pi) before the amplification of PrPCWD became detectable in tissues.
Recent studies have shown that PrPres is poorly preserved
after incubation with intestinal or fecal content (23, 24). Further research
using cervid and surrogate cervid PrP transgenic mice (25) are indicated to
continue to address the presence of infectious CWD prions in excreta of CWDž
deer and to provide a more substantial basis for reconsideration of the
assumption that excreta are the chief vehicle for CWDdissemination and
transmission. The results reported here provide a plausible basis for the
efficient transmission of CWD in nature. We demonstrate that blood and
saliva in particular are able to transmit CWD to naBve deer and produce
incubation periods consistent with those observed in naturally acquired
infections (3, 26). The time from exposure to first detection of PrPCWD by
tonsil biopsy was variable—as short as 3 months but as long as 18 months
(likely
underestimates due to sampling frequency). The results also reinforce a
cautious view of the exposure risk presented by body fluids, excreta, and
all tissues from CWDž cervids...
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/314/5796/133